Skip to main content

Find the Best Employee Benefit Brokers in Oklahoma

Our top 10 list features verified, licensed, and insured employee benefits brokers. Rankings are based on human research, licensure verification, and public record audits.

Top 10 Employee Benefits Brokers - Updated November, 2026

Business logo for Strategic Benefit Partners
Sponsored
Employer Size Expertise
Funding Strategy
Core Benefits Lines
Verified

Strategic Benefit Partners

  • Group medical insurance for small businessesEmployer-sponsored dental insurance plans
  • Group vision insurance coverageCOBRA continuation coverage administration
  • Employee disability insuranceGroup and voluntary life insurance

Woman-owned Norman small business health insurance brokerage that partners with small business owners to build valuable employee benefits packages including medical, dental, vision, COBRA, disability, 125/POP, life, and supplemental coverage to attract and retain quality employees and support long-term business success.

Pros

  • Woman-owned brokerage founded in 2019 by an owner with prior 9 years of industry experience focused exclusively on client-best-interest advice

Cons

  • Primarily oriented toward small to mid-sized employers rather than very large corporate accounts
Business logo for INSURICA
Employer Size Expertise
Funding Strategy
Core Benefits Lines
Voluntary & Perks
Verified

INSURICA

  • Employee benefits consulting and plan designCommercial property and casualty insurance
  • Workers’ compensation coveragePersonal home and auto insurance
  • In-house risk control and loss controlClaims advocacy for policyholders

INSURICA’s founding Oklahoma City location provides best-in-class insurance services to businesses and individuals, with separate departments for Commercial Property/Casualty, Employee Benefits, and Personal Insurance. Seasoned professionals deliver specialized expertise in construction, education, energy, financial, manufacturing, surety, ministries, and not-for-profits, supported by in-house risk control and claims advocates. Founded in 1959 as North American Insurance Agency and rebranded in 2009, the firm emphasizes client-centric culture, community involvement, and comprehensive risk management.

Pros

  • Dedicated Employee Benefits department with proven 4-step RM4U process covering risk assessment, reporting, performance planning, and stewardship for customized cost-effective programs.

Cons

  • Standard business hours limited to Monday-Friday 8:00 a.m. to 4:45 p.m. may require planning for after-hours needs.
Review Scores
Facebook4.8
Google4.3
Business logo for Gallagher Tulsa
Verified

Gallagher Tulsa

Gallagher in Tulsa provides insurance, risk management, and consulting services, including employee benefits and HR consulting. As part of a global firm with more than 90 years of experience, the office helps organizations with tailored risk assessment, benefits programs, property and casualty solutions, and strategies to invest in people and organizational wellbeing.

Pros

  • Offers comprehensive employee benefits and HR consulting backed by global resources and local Tulsa expertise

Cons

  • As a large global firm, service can feel more oriented toward bigger companies than very small businesses
Business logo for Oklahoma Employee Benefits & Insurance, LLC
Verified

Oklahoma Employee Benefits & Insurance, LLC

Oklahoma Employee Benefits & Insurance, LLC is an independent, privately owned insurance agency serving clients in the state of Oklahoma. Primary services are consultative, helping small business owners and individuals select, implement, and manage insurance and employee benefit plans. Specializes in group health, dental, vision, life, disability, long-term care, voluntary benefits, administrative and compliance services including cafeteria plans, HSAs, HRAs, COBRA, ERISA, executive benefits, and retirement plans through an affiliated adviser, with a focus on small businesses of 2 to 200 employees and self-employed individuals.

Pros

  • Independent agency offering unbiased multi-carrier options and customized plans without proprietary product pressure

Cons

  • Small team size may limit capacity for very large or highly complex multi-state accounts compared to national brokerages
Business logo for Eagle Group Associates, Inc.
Employer Size Expertise
Funding Strategy
Core Benefits Lines
Voluntary & Perks
Verified

Eagle Group Associates, Inc.

  • Group health insuranceMedicare Advantage and supplementsIndividual and family health plans
  • Term and whole life insuranceEmployee dental and visionVoluntary workplace benefits
  • 401(k) and retirement plansGroup life and AD&DShort- and long-term disability

Eagle Group Associates, Inc. is a local, family-run independent insurance agency in Oklahoma City serving individuals, families, seniors, and businesses since 1988. With over 100 years of combined experience, the agency provides Medicare solutions, individual and family health insurance, life insurance, and comprehensive employee benefits and group insurance programs. As an independent agency representing over 70 carriers, it designs tailored coverage options including group health, dental, vision, life, disability, retirement plans, voluntary benefits, and HR/enrollment support to help businesses attract and retain talent while ensuring compliance.

Pros

  • Family-owned independent agency since 1988 with access to 70+ carriers for customized comparisons and competitive pricing on group and individual plans

Cons

  • Standard office hours limited to Monday-Friday 9:00am-5:30pm with Saturdays by appointment only, which may require advance scheduling
Business logo for Employee Benefit Professionals, LLC
Firm Type
Core Benefits Lines
Regulatory & Compliance Support
HR Tech & Administration
Verified

Employee Benefit Professionals, LLC

  • Group health insuranceGroup dental and visionGroup life insuranceInsure Oklahoma guidance
  • COBRA and ERISA supportBenefits enrollment administrationMedicare supplement plans
  • Individual health and life insuranceWorkers compensation coverageBusiness owners policy

Employee Benefit Professionals, LLC is an independently owned Oklahoma City agency that designs group health, dental, vision, and life plans for employers of every size, then stays with those accounts through enrollment, renewals, and claims. From its office on Broadway Extension, the firm also shops commercial coverages such as business owners policies, liability, and workers’ compensation, along with individual health, life, disability, homeowners, auto, long-term care, and Medicare supplement options. Licensed in Oklahoma, Colorado, Kansas, and Texas, the shop works as a multi-carrier liaison rather than a single-company storefront, pairing each client with a dedicated team of licensed agents. Owners Mike O’Brien and Rebecca Vonfeldt built the practice around a straightforward idea: understand what the business owner needs first, then build a cost-effective package that can change as the workforce does. That same desk handles practical compliance help—COBRA, ERISA, FMLA, and Insure Oklahoma—so local companies have one place to call when benefits get complicated.

Pros

  • Independently owned agency providing creative, personalized, and cost-effective group health, dental, vision, and life insurance for businesses of all sizes

Cons

  • As a specialized benefits and insurance brokerage, offerings center on insurance products rather than broader full-service HR outsourcing or payroll
Business logo for Unity Insurance Partners - Edmond
Core Benefits Lines
Voluntary & Perks
Regulatory & Compliance Support
Firm Type
Verified

Unity Insurance Partners - Edmond

Unity Insurance Partners, part of the First United Family of Insurance Solutions, has served Oklahoma and Texas for over 100 years with tailored personal and business insurance. Offerings include commercial property and casualty, employee benefits such as group medical, dental, vision, life, AD&D, short- and long-term disability, voluntary benefits, HSAs and FSAs, plus personal home, auto and valuable articles coverage. The firm uses a consultative approach with local experts to design cost-effective programs and provide compliance support.

Pros

  • Provides full suite of employee benefits including group medical, dental, vision, life, AD&D, short- and long-term disability, voluntary benefits, HSAs and FSAs with compliance assistance for ACA and IRS requirements

Cons

  • Standard weekday business hours only with no publicly listed evening or weekend availability for in-person consultations
Business logo for Evans National Group
Verified

Evans National Group

Evans National is a fast-growing independent insurance agency and employee benefits broker based in Oklahoma City, offering tailored employee benefits solutions, commercial insurance, actuarial services, risk management, HR compliance and technology consulting, data analytics and benchmarking, wellness and population health management, and pharmacy benefits programs for businesses of all sizes. As a member of the Benefit Advisors Network, the firm provides expert guidance to help employers design cost-effective benefits packages that attract and retain talent while managing risk and ensuring compliance.

Pros

  • Offers comprehensive employee benefits solutions including medical, dental, vision, life, and financial protection tailored for small businesses and larger employers

Cons

  • Founded in 2019, the firm has a shorter operating history compared to long-established local brokers
Business logo for KEVO Benefits LLC
Verified

KEVO Benefits LLC

KEVO Benefits LLC is an independent insurance brokerage offering structured healthcare coverage solutions for individuals, families, and employers nationwide. It evaluates, compares, and recommends best-fit coverage from multiple providers, structuring plans in two parts: Everyday Care with fixed copays for doctor visits, prescriptions, and labs, plus Major Medical Sharing for hospitalizations and surgeries via community-based programs with provider advocacy that frequently reduces costs by 30–75%. It serves self-employed professionals, freelancers, families, and employers seeking predictable transparent group costs. Not traditional health insurance or an insurance carrier; health share memberships are community-based and do not meet ACA standards.

Pros

  • Independent brokerage that evaluates and compares coverage options from multiple providers for customized fits

Cons

  • Health share memberships are not traditional regulated insurance and do not meet ACA standards
Business logo for Rich & Cartmill, Inc.
Verified

Rich & Cartmill, Inc.

Rich & Cartmill, Inc. is one of the largest privately-held Trusted Choice independent insurance agencies in the country, established in 1922. The firm provides innovative commercial insurance solutions including personalized employee benefits programs with medical, dental, vision, life, disability, and worksite benefits to help businesses attract and retain talent while navigating regulatory requirements like the Affordable Care Act. Serving multiple industries from its Oklahoma City office and other locations, the agency emphasizes strategic protection plans, risk management, and exceptional service for businesses and individuals.

Pros

  • Century-plus track record since 1922 as a large privately held independent agency with deep expertise in employee benefits design

Cons

  • Larger multi-location structure may feel less personalized than smaller boutique brokers for some clients